{"id":"2026-10-06-canadian-dimension-the-fight-over-ai-data-centres-is-a-fight","kind":"oped","date":"2026-10-06","title":"The fight over AI data centres is a fight over local democracy","outlet":"Canadian Dimension","medium":"Op-ed","howFeatured":"Nick Tsergas; Dan Shannon","canonicalUrl":"https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/the-fight-over-ai-data-centres-is-a-fight-over-local-democracy","verification":"Verified","notes":"Article date Oct 6; site listing elsewhere says Oct 8. French translation exists.","text":{"status":"fetched","excerpt":"The fight over AI data centres is a fight over local democracy – Canadian Dimension Canadian Politics Economic Crisis Environment Europe Housing Indigenous Politics Labour Middle East Media Policing War Zones Africa Canada-USA Canadian Business Health Care Human Rights Education Culture Asia Feminism Food and Agriculture Globalization COVID-19 Latin America and the Caribbean Occupy Movement Quebec Far-Right En Français Queer Reviews Energy Science and Technology Social Movements Socialism Sports USA Politics…","bodyPlain":"The fight over AI data centres is a fight over local democracy – Canadian Dimension Canadian Politics Economic Crisis Environment Europe Housing Indigenous Politics Labour Middle East Media Policing War Zones Africa Canada-USA Canadian Business Health Care Human Rights Education Culture Asia Feminism Food and Agriculture Globalization COVID-19 Latin America and the Caribbean Occupy Movement Quebec Far-Right En Français Queer Reviews Energy Science and Technology Social Movements Socialism Sports USA Politics More Articles Columnists Videos Reviews Collections Cartoons The CD Archive Past Issues About Donate Submissions Advertise Search Search Please do not fill-in this field Advertisement The fight over AI data centres is a fight over local democracy Municipalities are pushing back against the erosion of their autonomy, with data centres the most visible flashpoint Nick Tsergas and Dan Shannon / October 8, 2026 / 3 min read Canadian Politics Science and Technology Photo by Rosa Menkman/ Flickr A reckoning is coming between municipalities and upper levels of government, and today’s AI data centre fights are the opening salvo. As provincial and federal governments race to build AI data centres, they’ve exposed a democratic faultline. Municipalities, the governments closest to the consequences, have the least power to decide what gets built and where. The dynamic isn’t limited to data centres and it’s not new. Nor is the idea, arising from constitutional law, that municipalities are mere “creatures of the provinces.” That is to say, our cities and towns are locally run, but ruled from afar by legislatures that can rearrange or combine them, nullify their bylaws, and dissolve them at will. It’s an odd notion, since many cities pre-date the provinces. And fortunately, there is precedent for reanimating “settled” constitutional debates such as this. Canadian law has long treated the Constitution as a “living tree,” capable of growth as circumstances change, and in need of occasional pruning. The late Canadian urban theorist Warren Magnusson challenged the logic directly, pointing out that no one would call First Nations “creatures of the federal government” just because the Constitution assigns Ottawa jurisdiction over them. But Canadian law does almost exactly that for cities. In 1993 the Supreme Court ruled on a case arising from Toronto’s crackdown on sidewalk vendors selling everything from flowers to knock-off T-shirts. One vendor, Morris Greenbaum, fatefully argued that the bylaw used to convict him went beyond the powers Ontario had actually given the city. The Court agreed in consequential fashion. “Municipalities are entirely the creatures of provincial statutes,” reads a line near the top of the decision . The problem with this interpretation is that municipalities look and behave much more like governments than mere creatures of provincial statute. Provinces don’t govern cities as branch offices, even though under this legal theory, they could if they wanted to. Instead, they establish elected municipal governments, and ask residents to hold those governments accountable for local decisions. Provinces have historically recognized the democratic value of local government. Nowadays, though, we see Ministerial Zoning Orders and the notwithstanding clause routinely deployed as tools of provincial overreach. It became clear municipalities were on a new battlefield when Doug Ford, shortly after becoming premier, slashed the size of Toronto City Council in the middle of the 2018 municipal elections. Though Ford’s move was struck down by Ontario’s Superior Court, he appealed and won. Ultimately, Canada’s Supreme Court heard the case and upheld Ford’s law, reiterating that a province has “absolute and unfettered legal power to do with [municipalities] as it wills.” The ruling was 5-4. All Canadians live in the shadow of these decisions, which hang over today’s fights around the Greenbelt, Toronto’s waterfront airport expansion, and AI data centres suddenly popping up everywhere. The Ford government is positioning data centres as strategic infrastructure and giving the province a stronger hand over which large loads can connect to the electricity grid. But municipalities are now pushing back in a widespread way on the continued erosion of their autonomy. Data centres are the most visible flashpoint. There are few better metaphors for centralised technocratic rule than hulking windowless blocks ringed by barbed wire. For municipalities, they’re a unique opportunity to reclaim power, and to coordinate. Just before Oakville council voted unanimously in August to implement a data-centre moratorium, Councillor Tom Adams said, “It’s not just an Oakville issue… it’s a Canada-wide and perhaps a North America-wide issue.” Adams spearheaded the successful push. Councillor Jeff Knoll agreed, noting the opportunity to “really engage our colleagues in other jurisdictions” in developing appropriate regulation for the new type of facility, which did not exist in Canada five years ago. Under eight years of Ford’s steady centralization of power, the creatures of the province may be mutating. Growing stiffer spines and perhaps waiting for their moment to instrumentally oppose years of constitutional overreach. The data centre debate might be municipalities’ best shot at closing a democratic gap so obviously present in the way our country is now governed. Nick Tsergas is a journalist and founder of Stop the Datacentre, a Canadian network of communities seeking enforceable rules for AI data centres. His work is now done in partnership with Small Change Fund. Dan Shannon is an artist and independent investigative journalist based in Hamilton, Ontario who runs the website BlunderValley.ca . We Need Your Help More than 75% of our operating budget comes to us in the form of donations from our readers. These donations help to pay our bills, and honorariums for some of our writers, photographers and graphic artists. Our supporters are part of everything we do. Donate Now Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. Advertisement Popular Stories Cutting through Ottawa’s red tape disinformation Canada must move beyond constructive engagement—Cuba needs our solidarity now Leilani Farha wants us to rethink everything we know about the housing crisis Canada can’t keep hiding behind Trump to protect Big Oil Who’s on the menu in Carney’s omnibus bill? Advertisement Advertisement Related Reading Labour School wars in Ontario: McKinsey consultants, eLearning, and wage cuts Emma Thompson / June 1, 2022 / 7 min read Canadian Politics We need to rethink (and shrink) roads, not build more highways Nick Grover / May 1, 2022 / 5 min read Canadian Politics Ford ramping up privatization of Ontario health care system Doreen Nicoll / May 3, 2022 / 6 min read Syndicated Canadian Politics Election primer: Ontario’s health care crisis Ontario Health Coalition / May 19, 2022 / 5 min read Canadian Politics This election, let’s reimagine public transport for people and the climate Shelagh Pizey-Allen and Zain Khurram / May 21, 2022 / 10 min read Canadian Politics Doug Ford’s ‘strong mayor’ system is an anti-democratic power play Ryan Kelpin / August 8, 2022 / 6 min read Support CD Today More than 75% of our operating budget comes to us in the form of donations from our readers. These donations help to pay our bills, and honorariums for some of our writers, photographers and graphic artists. Our supporters are part of everything we do. Donate Now Never Miss A Story Sign up for our email newsletter and get our news and analysis delivered on the regular. Sign Up About Donate CD Archive Submissions Advertise Contact Us Founded in 1963, Canadian Dimension is a forum for debate on important issues facing the Canadian Left today, and a source for analysis of national and regional politics, labour, economics, world affairs and art. Canadian Dimension is made possible by the support of these sustaining partners: We acknowledge the financial support of the Government of Canada. All content ©1963–2026 Canadian Dimension   |   Top of page","fetchedAt":"2026-11-14T18:33:59.810Z","ladderTier":"api","attribution":"Excerpt hosted on nicktsergas.ca for search indexing; canonical article remains at the publisher link."}}